$OBBBA Calculators
← Tips Deduction Calculator

Practice Problem: $30,000 of Qualified Tips, Solved

The most-assigned OBBBA tips question in accounting courses — a beverage server whose 2025 tips exceed the deduction cap. Full worked solution with the statute behind every number.

The short answer: Answer up front: the deduction is $25,000, not $30,000. The cap in IRC §224(b)(1) applies before anything else, so $30,000 of qualified tips gets you the maximum $25,000 — and the leftover $5,000 is taxed as ordinary income.

⚠️ This calculator provides estimates for informational and educational purposes only. It is not tax advice. Results are based on the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) and IRS Schedule 1-A. Consult a qualified tax professional for your specific situation.

The Problem

Nia works as a beverage server at a casino restaurant. In 2025 she received $30,000 in qualified tips — cash from customers, card tips routed through her employer, and her share of the tip pool. She reported everything to her employer, and the full amount is reflected on her W-2. Her MAGI is $120,000, single.

Question: how much of a tips deduction can she claim for 2025?

Step 1 — Qualify the Tips (IRC §224(d))

"Qualified tips" has a statutory definition, and every piece of Nia's $30,000 has to pass it:

  • • Cash tips — §224(d) counts cash, which includes credit and debit card tips. Her card tips and tip-pool share are in. ✓
  • • Tipped occupation — beverage service is an occupation that customarily and regularly received tips on or before December 31, 2024. ✓
  • • Voluntary — customers chose the amounts; no mandatory service charges are in the $30,000. (An automatic 18% gratuity on large parties would be wages, not tips.) ✓
  • • Reported — §224(a) requires the tips to appear on statements furnished to her (W-2, 1099) or on Form 4137. Hers are on the W-2. ✓

Result: $30,000 of qualified tips enters the formula.

Step 2 — Apply the Cap (IRC §224(b)(1)) — the Whole Point of the Problem

§224(b)(1): "The amount allowed as a deduction under this section for any taxable year shall not exceed $25,000." The deduction is the lesser of qualified tips and $25,000:

  • • Qualified tips: $30,000
  • • Statutory cap: $25,000
  • • Deduction: $25,000
  • • The extra $5,000: still taxable income, no OBBBA benefit

The problem hands you $30,000 precisely because it sits just over the cap. Any answer other than $25,000 means a step was skipped: $30,000 (missed the cap), $5,000 (deducted only the excess — backwards), or $6,600 (that is 22% of $30,000, confusing savings with deduction).

Step 3 — Check the Phase-Out (IRC §224(b)(2))

The deduction — now $25,000, after the cap — is reduced $100 per $1,000 of MAGI over $150,000 (single) or $300,000 (joint). Nia: $120,000 MAGI, single → under the threshold → no reduction. Final deduction: $25,000 on Schedule 1-A.

If the exam wanted the phase-out to matter it would place MAGI above the threshold — as in the bartender variant of this problem where filing status decides which threshold applies. Here it is a decoy: recognizing that it doesn't apply is part of the answer.

Step 4 — Reading the Answer Correctly

What the exam asksAnswer
"How much can she deduct?"$25,000
"How much tip income escapes tax?"$25,000 — the other $5,000 is fully taxed
"Tax saved, 22% bracket?"$25,000 × 22% = $5,500
"Does FICA go away?"No — 7.65% still applies to all $30,000

The deduction is an above-the-line adjustment on Schedule 1-A — she gets it whether or not she itemizes, and it stacks with the overtime premium deduction if she also worked overtime shifts.

The Template for Every Tips Exam Problem

  1. Qualify: cash/card tips, customarily tipped occupation (pre-2025), voluntary, reported on W-2/1099/Form 4137, tax year 2025–2028
  2. Cap: lesser of qualified tips or $25,000 per filer
  3. Phase-out: $100 off per $1,000 of MAGI over $150,000 single / $300,000 joint — check filing status first
  4. Report: what remains goes on Schedule 1-A; savings = deduction × marginal bracket

Sources: 26 U.S.C. §224 (OBBBA §70201, Public Law 119-21) for the definition, cap, phase-out, and 2028 termination; IRS Schedule 1-A for reporting. Plug in your own numbers on the tips deduction calculator or compare with the bartender $22,000 / $210,000-MAGI problem.

Frequently Asked Questions

A beverage server received $30,000 in qualified tips in 2025 — what is her deduction?

$25,000. IRC §224(b)(1) caps the tips deduction at $25,000, and the cap applies before the phase-out, so $30,000 of qualified tips yields a $25,000 deduction. The remaining $5,000 of tips is simply taxed as ordinary income. Assuming MAGI is under the phase-out threshold ($150,000 single / $300,000 joint), nothing further reduces it.

What makes tips 'qualified tips' under the OBBBA?

IRC §224(d): cash tips — which includes credit and debit card tips — received in an occupation that customarily and regularly received tips on or before December 31, 2024, provided by a customer who chose the amount. Beverage servers, servers, and bartenders all qualify. Mandatory service charges (like an automatic gratuity) are wages, not tips, and never-reported tips cannot be deducted because §224(a) requires the tips to appear on a W-2, an information return, or Form 4137.

Is the answer $30,000 or $25,000 — and why?

$25,000. The statute says the deduction is qualified tips 'not to exceed' $25,000. Cap first, phase-out second. Answering $30,000 means you skipped the cap — that is the exact error the problem is built to catch, since $30,000 is deliberately just above the limit.

How much tax does the $25,000 deduction save?

The deduction times the marginal bracket: $5,500 at 22%, $6,000 at 24%, $3,000 at 12%. If the exam asks for the deduction, answer $25,000; only if it asks for tax savings do you multiply by the bracket. FICA (7.65%) still applies to all $30,000 of tips regardless.

What if her MAGI were above the phase-out threshold?

Then the $25,000 starts shrinking by $100 per $1,000 of MAGI over $150,000 (single) or $300,000 (joint). Example: single with $170,000 MAGI → 20 × $100 = $2,000 off → $23,000 deduction. The full $25,000 disappears at $400,000 MAGI single / $550,000 joint.

Does the year matter in these problems?

Yes — the tips deduction exists only for tax years 2025 through 2028 (§224(h) terminates it after December 31, 2028). A 2025 or 2026 fact pattern qualifies; a 2024 one does not, and 'qualified tips' requires the occupation to have been customarily tipped on or before December 31, 2024.