Practice Problem: $30,000 of Qualified Tips, Solved
The most-assigned OBBBA tips question in accounting courses — a beverage server whose 2025 tips exceed the deduction cap. Full worked solution with the statute behind every number.
The short answer: Answer up front: the deduction is $25,000, not $30,000. The cap in IRC §224(b)(1) applies before anything else, so $30,000 of qualified tips gets you the maximum $25,000 — and the leftover $5,000 is taxed as ordinary income.
⚠️ This calculator provides estimates for informational and educational purposes only. It is not tax advice. Results are based on the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) and IRS Schedule 1-A. Consult a qualified tax professional for your specific situation.
The Problem
Nia works as a beverage server at a casino restaurant. In 2025 she received $30,000 in qualified tips — cash from customers, card tips routed through her employer, and her share of the tip pool. She reported everything to her employer, and the full amount is reflected on her W-2. Her MAGI is $120,000, single.
Question: how much of a tips deduction can she claim for 2025?
Step 1 — Qualify the Tips (IRC §224(d))
"Qualified tips" has a statutory definition, and every piece of Nia's $30,000 has to pass it:
- • Cash tips — §224(d) counts cash, which includes credit and debit card tips. Her card tips and tip-pool share are in. ✓
- • Tipped occupation — beverage service is an occupation that customarily and regularly received tips on or before December 31, 2024. ✓
- • Voluntary — customers chose the amounts; no mandatory service charges are in the $30,000. (An automatic 18% gratuity on large parties would be wages, not tips.) ✓
- • Reported — §224(a) requires the tips to appear on statements furnished to her (W-2, 1099) or on Form 4137. Hers are on the W-2. ✓
Result: $30,000 of qualified tips enters the formula.
Step 2 — Apply the Cap (IRC §224(b)(1)) — the Whole Point of the Problem
§224(b)(1): "The amount allowed as a deduction under this section for any taxable year shall not exceed $25,000." The deduction is the lesser of qualified tips and $25,000:
- • Qualified tips: $30,000
- • Statutory cap: $25,000
- • Deduction: $25,000
- • The extra $5,000: still taxable income, no OBBBA benefit
The problem hands you $30,000 precisely because it sits just over the cap. Any answer other than $25,000 means a step was skipped: $30,000 (missed the cap), $5,000 (deducted only the excess — backwards), or $6,600 (that is 22% of $30,000, confusing savings with deduction).
Step 3 — Check the Phase-Out (IRC §224(b)(2))
The deduction — now $25,000, after the cap — is reduced $100 per $1,000 of MAGI over $150,000 (single) or $300,000 (joint). Nia: $120,000 MAGI, single → under the threshold → no reduction. Final deduction: $25,000 on Schedule 1-A.
If the exam wanted the phase-out to matter it would place MAGI above the threshold — as in the bartender variant of this problem where filing status decides which threshold applies. Here it is a decoy: recognizing that it doesn't apply is part of the answer.
Step 4 — Reading the Answer Correctly
| What the exam asks | Answer |
|---|---|
| "How much can she deduct?" | $25,000 |
| "How much tip income escapes tax?" | $25,000 — the other $5,000 is fully taxed |
| "Tax saved, 22% bracket?" | $25,000 × 22% = $5,500 |
| "Does FICA go away?" | No — 7.65% still applies to all $30,000 |
The deduction is an above-the-line adjustment on Schedule 1-A — she gets it whether or not she itemizes, and it stacks with the overtime premium deduction if she also worked overtime shifts.
The Template for Every Tips Exam Problem
- Qualify: cash/card tips, customarily tipped occupation (pre-2025), voluntary, reported on W-2/1099/Form 4137, tax year 2025–2028
- Cap: lesser of qualified tips or $25,000 per filer
- Phase-out: $100 off per $1,000 of MAGI over $150,000 single / $300,000 joint — check filing status first
- Report: what remains goes on Schedule 1-A; savings = deduction × marginal bracket
Sources: 26 U.S.C. §224 (OBBBA §70201, Public Law 119-21) for the definition, cap, phase-out, and 2028 termination; IRS Schedule 1-A for reporting. Plug in your own numbers on the tips deduction calculator or compare with the bartender $22,000 / $210,000-MAGI problem.
Frequently Asked Questions
A beverage server received $30,000 in qualified tips in 2025 — what is her deduction?
$25,000. IRC §224(b)(1) caps the tips deduction at $25,000, and the cap applies before the phase-out, so $30,000 of qualified tips yields a $25,000 deduction. The remaining $5,000 of tips is simply taxed as ordinary income. Assuming MAGI is under the phase-out threshold ($150,000 single / $300,000 joint), nothing further reduces it.
What makes tips 'qualified tips' under the OBBBA?
IRC §224(d): cash tips — which includes credit and debit card tips — received in an occupation that customarily and regularly received tips on or before December 31, 2024, provided by a customer who chose the amount. Beverage servers, servers, and bartenders all qualify. Mandatory service charges (like an automatic gratuity) are wages, not tips, and never-reported tips cannot be deducted because §224(a) requires the tips to appear on a W-2, an information return, or Form 4137.
Is the answer $30,000 or $25,000 — and why?
$25,000. The statute says the deduction is qualified tips 'not to exceed' $25,000. Cap first, phase-out second. Answering $30,000 means you skipped the cap — that is the exact error the problem is built to catch, since $30,000 is deliberately just above the limit.
How much tax does the $25,000 deduction save?
The deduction times the marginal bracket: $5,500 at 22%, $6,000 at 24%, $3,000 at 12%. If the exam asks for the deduction, answer $25,000; only if it asks for tax savings do you multiply by the bracket. FICA (7.65%) still applies to all $30,000 of tips regardless.
What if her MAGI were above the phase-out threshold?
Then the $25,000 starts shrinking by $100 per $1,000 of MAGI over $150,000 (single) or $300,000 (joint). Example: single with $170,000 MAGI → 20 × $100 = $2,000 off → $23,000 deduction. The full $25,000 disappears at $400,000 MAGI single / $550,000 joint.
Does the year matter in these problems?
Yes — the tips deduction exists only for tax years 2025 through 2028 (§224(h) terminates it after December 31, 2028). A 2025 or 2026 fact pattern qualifies; a 2024 one does not, and 'qualified tips' requires the occupation to have been customarily tipped on or before December 31, 2024.