Practice Problem: Bartender, $22,000 of Tips, $210,000 MAGI
A fully worked OBBBA tips-deduction problem of the kind that shows up in accounting courses — cap, phase-out threshold by filing status, and the final answer, citing the statute at every step.
The short answer: Answer up front: the deduction is $22,000 — the full amount of qualified tips. The $25,000 cap never binds, and because the return is married filing jointly, the phase-out only starts at $300,000 MAGI, which $210,000 never reaches.
⚠️ This calculator provides estimates for informational and educational purposes only. It is not tax advice. Results are based on the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) and IRS Schedule 1-A. Consult a qualified tax professional for your specific situation.
The Problem
During 2025, Devi worked as a bartender at a busy restaurant. Over the year she received $22,000 in qualified tips — a mix of cash left on the bar and credit-card tips paid out in her paycheck — all of it reported to her employer and included on her W-2. She and her spouse file a joint return, and their modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) for the year is $210,000.
Question:how much can she deduct under the OBBBA "no tax on tips" provision, and where does it go on the return?
Step 1 — Confirm the Tips Are "Qualified"
IRC §224(d) (added by OBBBA §70201, Public Law 119-21) defines qualified tips as cash tips — including credit and debit card tips — received in an occupation that customarily and regularly received tips on or before December 31, 2024. Bartending plainly qualifies, cash and card tips both count, and nothing here is a mandatory service charge.
- • Bartending is a customarily tipped occupation ✓
- • Cash + card tips both count as cash tips under §224(d) ✓
- • All $22,000 was reported on her W-2, as §224(a) requires ✓
- • No mandatory service charges in the mix ✓
Result: the entire $22,000 enters the calculation as qualified tips.
Step 2 — Apply the $25,000 Cap
IRC §224(b)(1) limits the deduction to $25,000 per filer ($25,000 per spouse on a joint return). The rule is simple: the deduction is the lesser of qualified tips or $25,000.
- • Qualified tips: $22,000
- • Statutory cap: $25,000
- • Lesser of the two: $22,000 — the cap does not bind
This is the mirror image of the $30,000 server problem — here the examiner gives you a number underthe cap to test that you do not reflexively answer "$25,000."
Step 3 — Run the MAGI Phase-Out (the Real Trap)
IRC §224(b)(2) reduces the deduction by $100 for each $1,000 of MAGI over $150,000 — or $300,000 on a joint return. Devi files jointly, so:
- • Joint threshold: $300,000
- • MAGI: $210,000 → $210,000 < $300,000
- • Excess over threshold: $0 → phase-out reduction: $0
The trap: $210,000 looks high, and students who grab the $150,000 single-filer threshold compute 60 × $100 = $6,000 of reduction and answer $16,000. That is the most common wrong answer. Check the filing status before the threshold — the $150,000 / $300,000 pair is written directly into §224(b)(2)(A).
One more statutory detail for completeness: §224(b)(2)(B) defines MAGI here as AGI plus any income excluded under §911 (foreign earned), §931, or §933 — for a domestic bartender, that is simply line 11 of Form 1040.
Step 4 — The Answer and Where It Goes
- • Deduction: $22,000 (lesser of tips / cap, unphased)
- • Reported on IRS Schedule 1-A as an above-the-line OBBBA tips deduction — no itemizing required
- • Tax saved at a 22% marginal bracket: $22,000 × 22% = $4,840
- • FICA (7.65%) on the tips is unchanged — the provision is an income-tax deduction, not an exclusion
Note the distinction the problem is really testing: the deduction is $22,000; the savings($4,840 at 22%) is the deduction times the bracket. If the exam asks "how much can she deduct," the answer is $22,000 — never the savings figure.
The Same Problem, Three Ways
| Variant | Deduction | Why |
|---|---|---|
| As given (MFJ, $210,000 MAGI) | $22,000 | Below cap; below the $300,000 joint threshold |
| Same facts, filing single | $16,000 | $150,000 threshold: 60 × $100 = $6,000 off |
| MFJ, MAGI $325,000 | $19,500 | 25 × $100 = $2,500 off the $22,000 |
Every variant follows the same three moves in order — qualify → cap → phase-out. Do them in that order and these problems become mechanical.
Sources
- • IRC §224 (26 U.S.C. §224, added by OBBBA §70201, Public Law 119-21) — deduction, $25,000 cap, $150,000/$300,000 phase-out, MAGI definition, termination after 2028
- • IRS Schedule 1-A — where the tips deduction is reported
Run your own numbers on the tips deduction calculator, see the $30,000 server version of this problem, or read all four OBBBA deduction rules side by side. If your exam also covers the income side, the overtime deduction uses the same phase-out machinery with a $12,500/$25,000 cap.
Frequently Asked Questions
A bartender earned $22,000 in tips with $210,000 MAGI filing jointly — what is the deduction?
$22,000. The tips are below the $25,000 cap, and because the return is married filing jointly, the phase-out threshold is $300,000 MAGI — $210,000 is under it, so nothing is subtracted. The deduction equals the full $22,000 of qualified tips on Schedule 1-A.
Why is the phase-out threshold $300,000 and not $150,000 in this problem?
IRC §224(b)(2) uses $150,000 for most filers but $300,000 for a joint return. Because this taxpayer files married filing jointly, the $300,000 figure controls. Using $150,000 — and shaving $6,000 off the deduction — is the most common wrong answer on this problem.
What is the most common wrong answer on this problem?
$16,000, which comes from applying the single-filer $150,000 threshold to a joint return: ($210,000 − $150,000) ÷ $1,000 = 60 steps × $100 = $6,000 off, $22,000 − $6,000 = $16,000. Also wrong: $25,000 (deducting the cap when tips are below it) and $4,840 (that is the tax savings at 22%, not the deduction).
How much tax does the $22,000 deduction actually save?
The deduction times the marginal bracket. At 22%, $22,000 × 0.22 = $4,840; at 24%, $5,280; at 12%, $2,640. The deduction is the $22,000 figure on Schedule 1-A — the savings are separate and depend on the taxpayer's bracket.
Do the bartender's credit-card tips count as qualified tips?
Yes. IRC §224(d) counts cash tips — which includes credit and debit card tips passed through the employer — received in an occupation that customarily and regularly received tips on or before December 31, 2024. Bartending qualifies. Mandatory service charges do not, and the tips must have been reported on a W-2, a 1099, or Form 4137.
Would the answer change if the couple's MAGI were $310,000 instead of $210,000?
Yes. At $310,000 MAGI on a joint return, the phase-out applies: $10,000 over $300,000 → 10 × $100 = $1,000 reduction, so the deduction drops from $22,000 to $21,000. The cap ($25,000) still never binds because the tips themselves are only $22,000.